Archives: Property Damage & Business Interruption

Subscribe to Property Damage & Business Interruption RSS Feed

An insurance company’s generic reservation of right can lead to a Waiver of a Late Notice Defense

By Anthony B. Crawford on Posted in Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Property Damage & Business Interruption
For insurance recovery attorneys, one of the more frustrating ways for a policyholder to lose coverage for a property loss is on the basis of late notice. Property insurance policies generally require the policyholder to give the insurance company “prompt notice” of claims and potential claims. Property policies may specify a timeframe in which the … Continue Reading

Too damaged to repair? How to maximize your insurance recovery

By Andrew Roman on Posted in Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Property Damage & Business Interruption
When a loss event badly damages a key piece of equipment or machinery, an insured business often faces the complicated question: repair or replace? This is especially so when the extent of the damage is unclear because some may still be hidden. A business presented with this dilemma is well advised to go through that … Continue Reading

A tale of two opinions: The meaning of “physical loss” in the context of commercial property policies for Covid-19-related losses in Pennsylvania

By Andrew Kintner and Max Louik on Posted in COVID-19, Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Property Damage & Business Interruption
With the onset of the Covid-19 pandemic in 2020, businesses across the country were forced to shut their doors and turn to their commercial property insurance companies to seek coverage. With their properties having been rendered useless for their intended (and insured) business purposes, these insureds reasonably expected their “all risk” policies would provide the promised … Continue Reading

Physical loss and reasonable expectations of policyholders: The Third Circuit whiffs

By Douglas C. Rawles on Posted in COVID-19, Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Property Damage & Business Interruption
On January 6, 2023, the Third Circuit affirmed lower court rulings in 14 consolidated appeals from orders dismissing claims for property damage and business interruption losses resulting from the coronavirus and/or COVID-19. Policyholder lawyers can (and will) find fault with many parts of Wilson v. USI Ins. Service LLC, Case No. 20-3124, in which the Third … Continue Reading

COVID-19 business income claims – Will state appellate courts reject federal court predictions as to state law?

By Rich Lewis on Posted in Business interruption, COVID-19, Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Property Damage & Business Interruption
In the past few months, in cases considering whether SARS-CoV-2/COVID-19 can cause direct physical loss or damage to property so as to trigger business income coverage, policyholders have secured three wins in state appellate courts: Ungarean in the Superior Court of Pennsylvania, Huntington Ingalls in the Vermont Supreme Court, and Cajun Conti in the Louisiana … Continue Reading

Hurricane Ian and Hurricane Nicole: Answering questions policyholders frequently ask (or should ask) to ensure maximum recovery

By Jessica E. Gopiao and Matthew B. Weaver on Posted in Business interruption, Environmental, Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Property Damage & Business Interruption
At $40-70 billion in estimated insured losses, Hurricane Ian is the nation’s second most expensive natural disaster for the insurance industry. Less than two months later, Hurricane Nicole made landfall in Florida. Securing insurance coverage for these losses will be an important part of rebuilding and recovery. Recently, Reed Smith’s insurance coverage lawyers hosted a … Continue Reading

Maximizing recovery for combined wind and flood damages in hurricane claims

By Maria Castro Sanchez and Matthew B. Weaver on Posted in Business interruption, Insurance General, Property Damage & Business Interruption
This year, Hurricane Ian swept through the Southeastern United States, causing extensive damage to property in the affected areas. While obtaining insurance recoveries for any loss can be a complex endeavor, recovery for hurricane loss is particularly complex, as it typically involves a mix of covered and excluded perils. Most standard homeowners or other property … Continue Reading

Amy’s Kitchen: A step in the right direction

By Adrienne N. Kitchen and Douglas C. Rawles on Posted in COVID-19, Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Property Damage & Business Interruption
On October 4, the California First Appellate District in Amy’s Kitchen, Inc. v. Fireman’s Fund Insurance Company, 2022 Cal. App. LEXIS 836, reversed a trial court’s order granting the insurer’s demurrer in a COVID-19 property damage claim, and remanded to allow the policyholder to amend its allegations of loss under a communicable disease coverage extension.  … Continue Reading

Looking beyond “Physical Damage to Property”: Is Marina Pacific Hotel a winning framework for policyholders?

By Claire Whitehead and John Vishneski on Posted in Business interruption, COVID-19, Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Property Damage & Business Interruption
It’s no secret that businesses of all shapes and sizes have suffered tremendous losses during the COVID-19 pandemic. From closures to the “Great Resignation” to ever-changing consumer demands, businesses have dealt with one problem after another. One of those problems is the denial of insurance coverage under  “all risk” commercial property policies. For the last … Continue Reading

Two state Supreme Courts reach commercially reasonable results by permitting post-loss assignments  

By Lisa Szymanski and Nicholas Rodriguez on Posted in Commercial General Liability, Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Property Damage & Business Interruption
The well-established principle that a policyholder may assign benefits under an insurance policy following a loss was recently reaffirmed by state supreme courts in two jurisdictions:  South Carolina and Puerto Rico. These two jurisdictions join the majority rule, which holds that assignments following an insured loss are permissible because they do not change the scope … Continue Reading

Florida: the time to move for attorney’s fees post-appraisal

By Wesley Butensky and Christopher Kuleba on Posted in Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Property Damage & Business Interruption
Most residential property policies provide for an “appraisal” as an alternative dispute resolution mechanism when the insurer concedes coverage for a loss in whole or part, but the amount of the loss is disputed. The resulting appraisal award is binding on the parties absent certain limited grounds for challenging the award or the insurer’s obligation … Continue Reading

FCA v. Arch and others – The UK Supreme Court’s final word on business interruption insurance losses in light of the COVID-19 pandemic

By Peter Hardy, Margaret Campbell, Mark Pring, Laura-May Scott, Catherine Lewis, Emily McMahan, Charlotte Stewart-Jones and Thomas Morgan on Posted in Insurance Coverage, Property Damage & Business Interruption
The United Kingdom Supreme Court (UKSC) handed down its judgment on 15 January 2021 in The Financial Conduct Authority v. Arch Insurance (UK) Limited and Others. This test case was brought by the FCA on behalf of SME business interruption (BI) policyholders who have suffered financial losses as a result of COVID-19. The High Court … Continue Reading

Join us for an on-demand webinar “What policyholders really need to know about insurance for COVID-19”

By Elizabeth F. Vieyra on Posted in Commercial General Liability, D&O, E&O, Professional Liability, Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Property Damage & Business Interruption, Uncategorized
Reed Smith Insurance Recovery partners John Shugrue, John Ellison, Amber Finch, Richard Lewis, and Matthew Weaver offer discussion and analysis on key issues relevant to businesses seeking, or evaluating whether to seek, coverage for COVID-19 losses. This webinar is available on demand and you can register here. Here’s a brief summary of the topics addressed in … Continue Reading

Pollution exclusion should not preclude coverage for virus-related claims

By Mike Sampson on Posted in Commercial General Liability, Construction Coverage, Corporate and Transactional Insurance Coverage, Cyberliability, D&O, E&O, Professional Liability, Employment Practices Liability, Financial Insurance Coverage, Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Insurance Insolvency & Regulatory, Insurance News of Note, London/Bermuda Arbitrations, Property Damage & Business Interruption, Uncategorized
Faced with mounting claims for insurance coverage as a result of the novel coronavirus (COVID-19) outbreak, commercial insurers are likely to search for any policy provision that they think will enable them to avoid paying virus-related claims.  One provision that insurers ultimately may invoke in an attempt to deny such claims is the so-called “pollution … Continue Reading

Raccoons as legal roadkill: The Western District of Pennsylvania denies coverage for damage caused by masked bandits

By Mike Sampson and Kateri Persinger on Posted in Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Insurance News of Note, Property Damage & Business Interruption
Reviewing philosopher Mark Rowlands’ 2012 work Can Animals Be Moral?, Jessica Pierce wrote in the Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews, “The question, ‘Can animals be moral?’ has suffered the worst kind of philosophical denial: an almost complete lack of interest by ‘serious’ philosophers.” No longer.  In an effort to apply “general canon[s] of contract interpretation,” the … Continue Reading

CannaBeware: Make sure insurance actually covers the risks your business faces

By Mike Sampson on Posted in Commercial General Liability, Corporate and Transactional Insurance Coverage, D&O, E&O, Professional Liability, Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Insurance News of Note, Property Damage & Business Interruption
It should go without saying that when a business purchases any insurance policy – including, but not limited to, a commercial general liability (CGL) insurance policy – the business expects the policy to provide coverage for its line of business and the specific risks it faces. Cannabis-related businesses are no different. However, they must be … Continue Reading

Should the Cannabis Industry Fear the Sixth Circuit and K.V.G.?

By Mike Sampson on Posted in Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Insurance News of Note, Property Damage & Business Interruption
Although any case has the potential to go sideways, the appeal in K.V.G. Properties, Inc. v. Westfield Insurance Company – which involves a policyholder’s right to insurance coverage for property damaged by a third party’s marijuana growing operation – should not be cause for alarm in the cannabis industry. As driven home by the opening … Continue Reading

Marijuana and the “Illegal/Dishonest Acts Exclusion”: Making Sense of K.V.G. Properties, Inc. v. Westfield Insurance Company

By Mike Sampson on Posted in Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Insurance News of Note, Property Damage & Business Interruption
A recent federal court decision in “a property loss insurance case” involving the unauthorized growing of marijuana could have a negative impact on the enforceability of insurance policies sold to legitimate marijuana-related businesses. How much of an effect remains to be seen, but there is reason to think it should be minimal. At issue in … Continue Reading

Insurance Recovery Tips for Companies Suffering Damage after Recent Disasters: 2017 Hurricanes (Harvey, Irma, Maria, Nate), Earthquake (Mexico City), and Wine Country Wildfires (California)

By John Shugrue, James M. Davis and Kevin Dreher on Posted in Insurance Coverage, Property Damage & Business Interruption
Companies are facing operational and logistical challenges in recovering from the widespread destruction caused by these natural disasters. They will be looking to property damage and business interruption insurance to get them back on track. The time and cost to return to normal operations could be unusually long given the widespread destruction and the lack … Continue Reading

In Wake of Disasters, Do Not Just Assume No Coverage Available for Cannabis-Related Losses

By Mike Sampson and Cristina Shea on Posted in Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Insurance News of Note, Property Damage & Business Interruption
As reported extensively in the media over the past week, the cannabis industry has been hit hard by recent natural disasters. While companies doing business in this industry may face some unique challenges in purchasing insurance, and when attempting to obtain coverage for losses, insurance coverage – contrary to certain media reports – nevertheless may … Continue Reading

Disaster Relief Resources For Individuals After Hurricanes Harvey And Irma

By James M. Davis and Emily Garrison on Posted in Insurance Coverage, Property Damage & Business Interruption
Hurricanes Harvey and Irma have brought widespread destruction and extraordinary damage to property that will require a long recovery. Individuals will need substantial relief to replace and repair homes and personal property. This blog provides guidance about insurance and governmental resources available to assist individuals after these Hurricanes and discusses common issues and questions arising … Continue Reading

Texas Legislature Votes to Restrict Policyholders’ Rights

By Jim Cooper and Luke Debevec on Posted in Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Property Damage & Business Interruption
Texas lawmakers are now on the fast track to restrict policyholders’ rights when their insurance companies fail to pay property insurance claims arising out of weather events, such as storms involving heavy winds and hail. Now that the Texas Senate has approved House Bill 1774, Governor Abbott is almost sure to sign it.  Unfortunately, this … Continue Reading

Schrödinger’s Coverage: When a Risk is Covered and Not Covered by Insurance

By Andy Moss on Posted in Commercial General Liability, Cyberliability, D&O, E&O, Professional Liability, Employment Practices Liability, Financial Insurance Coverage, Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Property Damage & Business Interruption
When is a person an “employee” under one insurance policy but not an employee under another?   Conflicting or inconsistent definitions across multiple policy lines issued to the same company can give rise to significant gaps in insurance coverage, as a recent opinion of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit instructs, Telamon Corp. … Continue Reading

Eighth Circuit pollution-exclusion opinion a cautionary tale for natural gas industry

By Mike Sampson on Posted in Commercial General Liability, Construction Coverage, Insurance Coverage, Insurance General, Insurance News of Note, Property Damage & Business Interruption
The interpretation and application of a pollution exclusion in a commercial general liability (“CGL”) policy is often a fact-specific and jurisdiction-specific exercise. That said, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit’s recent decision, applying North Dakota law and interpreting such an exclusion in a CGL policy, should command the attention of the entire … Continue Reading
LexBlog